Welcome to Joe and Mimi's Pizzeria
At Joe and Mimi's Pizzeria, nestled in Granville, Ohio, every slice tells a story steeped in authentic New York style. With a commitment to quality and tradition, Joe and Mimi craft an enticing menu featuring not only stellar pizzas but also mouthwatering calzones, pasta, and fresh salads. Renowned for their attention to detail, guests rave about the delightful flavors and homemade ingredients. Despite its cozy, take-out only setting, the warm atmosphere radiates from the friendly staff and owners, reminding patrons that great food comes with personal connection. Discover the true taste of New York right here in Granville!
-
943 River Rd, Granville, OH 43023 Hotline: (740) 587-0046
Welcome to Joe and Mimi's Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled at 943 River Rd, Granville, OH 43023. This cozy pizzeria specializes in authentic New York style pizza, bringing the essence of the Big Apple right to the heart of Granville. With a commitment to quality and a passion for good food, Joe and Mimi's has quickly become a favorite among locals.
The moment you step into this quaint establishment, the aromatic scent of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese fills the air. Although this spot is primarily a takeout place, the few tables inside are a testament to a welcoming atmosphere where great food and friendly service go hand in hand.
- Gourmet Pizzas: The standout item on the menu is undoubtedly their pizza. Customer reviews, like those from Joanne H. and Shellie E., rave about the rich flavors and authentic crust that show why they claim it to be New York style. With toppings like pepperoni, onion, tomato, and hot peppers, each bite offers a delightful explosion of taste.
- Irresistible Pastries & Sides: Besides their stellar pizza, Joe and Mimi's also serves up a variety of delicious pastries, calzones, and an antipasto salad that draws regular praise. The Spinach Calzone and Stuffed Cheese Bread are highly recommended for those craving a twist on traditional pizza fare.
- Substantial Subs: The menu also features hot subs, including classic options such as Meatball and Italian, perfect for a hearty meal on the go.
Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, some experiences have highlighted challenges with customer service. As noted by Jennifer F., the owner's demeanor can be a bit gruff, but the remarkable quality of food often outweighs this aspect for many patrons. Mike K. serves as a prime example of how the flavors found within these walls make the trip worthwhile, even for those who may have reservations about the atmosphere.
For those craving a slice of authentic New York pizza, be sure to plan ahead, as Joe and Mimi's Pizzeria operates primarily on a takeout basis, and hours can vary. Be ready for a culinary journey that promises to leave you satisfied and eager for more. Your taste buds will thank you!
For orders and inquiries, you can call them at (740) 587-0046. Trust us; this is one stop you won’t want to miss during your culinary travels in Granville!
The best NY style pies in the area .Excellent service ,very friendly staff and owners.
Amazing pizza! Service is great! Take out only. New York style. Make sure you order ahead. Check hours not open every day! Great people!
Pizza good. The family loves it. Owner never has been nice to me. Gruff. Not sure why. I am respectful to everyone. I order and my husband picks it up so I don't have to feel bad over and over again. Stars are based on pizza minus a star for the customer service.
Wow! We recently moved to Granville and have been trying out some of the pizza places. We thoroughly enjoyed our large pepperoni, onion, tomato and hot pepper pizza! They are not lying when they say it is New York pizza - it is!! Really authentic and so delicious. Highly recommend! We picked it up and placed it in a 350 degree confection oven for 5 minutes and it was perfect. We also had 2 side salads with fresh cut greens and just real veggies - no cheese or croutons
Awesome... I was a little concerned because their dinning room only had 3 tables in it and it was a little off the beaten path. I was truly surprised at how good the food was. We started out with the antipasto salad which was great (it was kind of a shame I did not get a pic of it because it looked as good as it tasted). The wifie had their Italian sub which was AWESOME. I had the pizza rollover or something like that which was a meat filled stromboli which was AWESOME. I am excited about stopping back to try the pizza. I strongly recommend that you stop in if you are in Granville and hungry. The owner was super nice and provided great service. Yes this is a 5 star review of a take out pizza shop with only 3 tables inside but it is that good.